Asttero

Which Payment Gateway Should You Choose for Your Shopify Store?

Shopify Published May 11, 2026 Updated June 15, 2026 8 min
Which Payment Gateway Should You Choose for Your Shopify Store?

The way you process transactions in an online store directly affects e-commerce business profitability. This decision shapes the shopping experience for customers, translating into conversion rate and number of completed orders. On Shopify, this issue is crucial due to the platform's specific fee structure and available integrations. At turnover of at least PLN 80,000–100,000 per month, it is worth thoroughly analyzing the total cost of ownership (TCO) of the payment system. Proper configuration helps reduce operating costs and limit abandoned cart problems. Which payment gateway should you choose for your Shopify store to balance buyer convenience with margin maximization?

Which Payment Gateway Should You Choose for Your Shopify Store?

Why Choosing a Payment Gateway on Shopify Is a Business Decision, Not a Technical One

Payment integration is much more than a technical step in launching a store. It is a strategic business decision that directly affects financial liquidity, fee levels, and user shopping behavior. Every additional click, unnecessary redirect, or missing preferred payment method in the cart creates risk of losing the customer at the final stage of the sales funnel.

For a business generating regular revenue of tens or hundreds of thousands of PLN per month, even minimal differences in operator fees generate significant amounts over a year. A difference of 0.5% at turnover of PLN 200,000 per month means savings or loss of PLN 12,000 annually on gateway fees alone. Added to this is the key indicator of conversion rate (CVR). Optimizing the payment process allows direct impact on this parameter by making it easier for customers to complete transactions.

A convenient and fast purchase process also allows you to effectively increase average order value. Customers more willingly add extra products when they know payment will take just a few seconds. The choice of payment operator also determines how quickly funds are credited to the company account, which is crucial for maintaining financial liquidity.

How Does Shopify Settle Payments? Shopify Payments vs External Gateways

Understanding Shopify's billing model is essential for making the optimal financial decision. The platform offers two main approaches to transaction processing: using native Shopify Payments or integration with external providers (third-party providers). The choice between these two models has a fundamental impact on the store's operating cost structure.

Shopify Payments is the platform's official payment system, fully available to sellers registered in Poland. Its main business advantage is that activating this solution exempts the store from additional transaction fees charged by Shopify on every sale. Using Shopify Payments, you pay only the standard card transaction fee (depending on your subscription plan), and the payment process is fully integrated with the admin panel.

Implementing an external payment gateway as the sole solution involves double costs. The seller must then pay the fee negotiated with the external operator plus an additional Shopify fee for processing transactions outside their native system.

Additional Shopify Transaction Fees Without Shopify Payments

If you decide to use only an external payment provider, Shopify charges an additional transaction fee on every order. The amount of this fee is strictly tied to the subscription plan your store uses:

For growing e-commerce generating turnover above PLN 100k per month, these additional percentage points mean thousands of PLN paid to the platform every month. For example, on the Shopify plan at PLN 150,000 turnover, the additional cost of using only an external gateway is PLN 1,500 per month, excluding the operator's own fee. Therefore, the optimal TCO solution is a hybrid model: activating Shopify Payments to eliminate transaction fees plus parallel implementation of an external operator to handle specific local payment methods.

Best Payment Gateways for Shopify in Poland—Operator Comparison

The Polish e-commerce market is characterized by unique consumer preferences—customers use traditional payment cards less often in favor of fast transfers (pay-by-link) and BLIK. To effectively adapt a Shopify store to the Polish market, integrating an operator that flawlessly handles these methods is essential.

Among Polish payment providers integrated with Shopify, the most popular solutions are:

For brands conducting international (cross-border) sales, Polish operators may prove insufficient. In such scenarios, implementing solutions such as Stripe or Mollie becomes crucial. Stripe is the global standard for card payments, offering powerful API and seamless support for dozens of currencies. Mollie, in turn, works excellently in Western Europe, enabling easy launch of local payment methods such as iDEAL in the Netherlands or Bancontact in Belgium as confirmed by the official Mollie integration for Shopify.

Standard pricing presented on payment operator websites is intended for beginner sellers. Stores generating stable turnover above PLN 100k per month can individually negotiate fee rates. Reducing fees by 0.2–0.4% at high transaction volume brings measurable savings that directly increase operational business profitability.

BLIK on Shopify—How to Ensure the Fastest Purchase Path?

BLIK revolutionized Polish e-commerce. According to market reports, this payment method is the most frequently chosen by Polish consumers shopping online. For a store owner, this means one thing: missing convenient and fast BLIK payment in checkout drastically reduces the chance of completing a transaction.

Traditional external gateway integration often forces the customer through a complicated path. After clicking buy, there is a redirect to the payment operator's page, the user must select the BLIK icon, copy the code from the banking app, confirm the transaction on the phone, and wait to return to the store. Every such redirect lengthens transaction time and increases the risk of technical error or customer abandonment.

The solution is implementing BLIK payment at the native Shopify checkout level (so-called BLIK One-Click). This allows the customer to enter the 6-digit code directly on the order summary page without redirects to external services. The entire process stays within one domain, which speeds up purchase and builds a sense of security. Such purchase path optimization can contribute to fewer abandoned carts and higher conversion rate.

One-Click Payments and Abandoned Carts on Mobile Devices

Traffic from mobile devices generates a significant share of visits in modern e-commerce. At the same time, mobile is where the highest abandoned cart rate is recorded. The main cause is the hassle of manually entering address and card details on a small phone screen.

Implementing One-Click payments such as Apple Pay, Google Pay, and Shop Pay completely eliminates this barrier. These solutions securely store user address and payment data, so completing a purchase comes down to one click and biometric authorization (e.g. Face ID or fingerprint).

User behavior analysis clearly shows that simplifying this final step is crucial for recovering abandoned carts on Shopify. When a customer can buy on the way to work, standing in line, or while browsing social media without searching for a wallet and copying card numbers, the probability of completing a transaction increases. Integrating these express payment methods directly on the product page or in the first cart step is one of the most effective methods of mobile conversion optimization.

How to Choose and Implement a Payment System? Step-by-Step Process

Implementing an optimal payment system requires a systematic approach that combines cost analysis with technical stability. It is worth dividing this selection process into several stages:

  1. Sales structure analysis—determine the share of domestic and foreign transactions to choose priority payment methods.
  1. TCO calculation—compare operator fees with Shopify fees and assess hybrid model profitability with Shopify Payments.
  1. Terms negotiation—contact operators to obtain individual fee rates at higher turnover.
  1. Integration and configuration—implement gateways in the Shopify panel and optimize visibility of express payment buttons.
  1. UX testing—verify correct operation of test transactions before official launch.

If you are planning checkout optimization, platform migration, or need support with advanced payment integration, professional Shopify store development by our experts helps you avoid costly technical mistakes. As an experienced Shopify agency we help configure gateways and analyze purchase data to choose solutions that maximize your business profitability.

FAQ

Yes, Shopify allows simultaneous use of Shopify Payments (for card payments, Apple Pay, Google Pay) and an external provider (e.g. for BLIK and fast transfers in Poland). This is the optimal configuration for cost and customer convenience.

Yes, Shopify Payments meets the highest security standards, including PCI DSS Level 1 certification. Transactions are fully encrypted, which minimizes financial abuse risk and ensures customer data security.

The key to lowering rates is turnover volume. Stores generating above PLN 100k monthly revenue should contact the operator's sales department directly (e.g. PayU, Tpay) to negotiate individual fee terms.

International transactions may incur additional currency conversion fees and higher rates for cards outside the European Economic Area. Detailed terms depend on the chosen Shopify plan.

Payout timing depends on the operator. With Shopify Payments in Poland, funds are usually transferred to the bank account within 2–3 business days from transaction authorization.

Bibliography